How To Play: Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases – Setup, rule summary and strategy

Quick Summary

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases offers an immersive and captivating gaming experience for fans of mystery and deduction. With a well-crafted storyline set in Victorian London, players will embark on a challenging journey, employing their detective skills to solve intricate cases.

Effective planning and strategy are key to success in this game. Players must carefully gather and interpret clues, manage their time, and make efficient use of resources. With each expansion case, the challenge deepens, providing hours of engaging gameplay.

The game emphasizes cooperation, allowing players to combine their deductive reasoning to crack the cases. Collaboration and sharing of insights play a pivotal role, enhancing the gameplay experience for all participants.

With high-quality components, detailed casebooks, and realistic artwork, the game immerses players in the ambiance of Victorian London. The inclusion of official solutions invites players to compare their deductions, providing valuable learning opportunities to refine their detective skills.

Whether you're a fan of Sherlock Holmes or simply enjoy unraveling mysteries, Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective offers an unforgettable experience that will keep you hooked from start to finish. Take on the role of the brilliant detective, step into the foggy streets of London, and let your investigative instincts guide you to solve the unsolvable.


Welcome to our comprehensive strategy guide for Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases! If you’re eager to conquer the challenging mysteries and emerge as a master detective, you’ve come to the right place. This guide provides an in-depth exploration of the game rules and offers top-notch strategies to maximize your chances of success.

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective immerses players in the intricate mysteries of Victorian London, where you and your fellow detectives will aspire to solve a series of captivating cases. Each case presents a unique puzzle for you to unravel, as you gather clues, interview suspects, and explore the streets of London to uncover the truth. The game’s engrossing storyline, high-quality components, and cooperative gameplay provide an unforgettable experience for those seeking a stimulating and thrilling gaming adventure.

In this guide, we’ll dive into every aspect of the game, from the game setup and gameplay mechanics to interpreting clues and managing your time effectively. We’ll discuss essential strategies that will enhance your investigation skills, as well as examining the importance of reviewing official solutions. With our expert guidance, you’ll arm yourself with the knowledge and tools necessary to crack the most challenging cases with confidence.

Get ready to channel your inner detective, exercise your deduction skills, and triumph as a master solver of mysteries. Let’s embark on this exciting journey through the streets of Victorian London, where the truth awaits your astute observation and keen intellect!

What’s in the box

  • Game board
  • Rulebook
  • London Directory
  • Watson’s Wharf Newspaper
  • The Times newspaper
  • Adfiles document envelope
  • Cases book with 10 cases
  • Map of London
  • London Time Track
  • Case solved tokens
  • Newspaper Locations game marker
  • London Times Newspaper Locations game marker
  • 2 Six-sided dice

How To Play Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases: Rules Summary

  1. Place the game board, casebook, newspapers, and the directory in the center of the table.
  2. Give each player a map of London and a directory.
  3. The casebook holds the mysteries you need to solve.
  4. Take note of the London Time Track and case solved tokens.
  5. Initialize the newspaper locations game markers for Watson’s Wharf and The Times newspaper.
Game Rounds and Turns
  1. Each game round represents a day of investigation.
  2. Begin by reading the case introduction in the casebook, outlining the mystery.
  3. Players take turns choosing and reading locations to investigate.
  4. Read the corresponding entry in the casebook for the chosen location.
  5. Gather information, clues, and any additional leads mentioned in the passages.
  6. Decide together which location to visit next.
  7. Use the directory to find pages referenced in the casebook for further reading.
Time Management and Scoring
  1. Avoid wasting time by managing your investigations efficiently.
  2. Make note of each lead you follow and the time spent on it.
  3. At the end of the game, check your solution by comparing it with the official one in the casebook.
  4. Earn points based on your accuracy and efficiency.
  5. Earn bonus points for correctly answering questions specific to each case.
  6. Considering how many locations you visited, restrictions broken, and the time it took, calculate your final score according to the provided guidelines.
  7. Strive to improve your score in subsequent cases.

Mastering the rules of Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases is vital for your success in solving each case. By familiarizing yourself with the setup, understanding game rounds and turns, and effectively managing your time and scoring, you’ll immerse yourself in a captivating detective experience that will test your deductive skills.

Best Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective The Thames Murders Other Cases Strategies

Planning Your Investigation

To successfully solve the intricate mysteries in Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases, effective planning of your investigation is essential. Here are some strategies to help you navigate through the complex puzzle.

Gather all available information
  1. Thoroughly examine the casebook and read every detail.
  2. Pay close attention to witness statements, newspaper articles, and any other relevant sources.
  3. Keep a note of important characters, locations, and events.
Create a structured approach
  1. Organize your investigation by dividing the available leads into different categories.
  2. Prioritize leads based on their significance and relevance to the case.
  3. Develop a timeline or flowchart to better visualize your progression and any potential connections.
Follow logical reasoning
  1. Analyze the evidence carefully to identify possible connections and patterns.
  2. Pay attention to inconsistencies and discrepancies that could uncover crucial information.
  3. Use deductive reasoning to form hypotheses and establish logical theories as you progress.
Collaborate and share insights
  1. Engage in open discussions and brainstorming sessions with your fellow players.
  2. Share discoveries, theories, and clues with each other.
  3. Consider different perspectives and approaches, as diverse insights can lead to breakthroughs.

Proper planning and strategizing will not only streamline your investigation but also enhance your chances of solving the complex cases efficiently. Take your time, analyze all available information, and collaborate effectively to uncover the truth behind The Thames Murders and other gripping mysteries.

Maximizing Efficiency

Achieving maximum efficiency in Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases is crucial to solve the mysteries within the allotted time. Here are some strategies to help you make the most of your investigation and optimize your efficiency:

Prioritize leads
  1. Identify key leads that are likely to provide the most significant clues.
  2. Focus your efforts on leads that directly relate to the main storyline.
  3. Consider the potential impact of each lead on narrowing down the suspects.
Utilize effective note-taking
  1. Keep well-organized and detailed notes of all the information you gather.
  2. Create separate sections to categorize clues, suspects, locations, and other relevant details.
  3. Use abbreviations and symbols to save time while jotting down important information.
Opt for strategic travel
  1. Plan your routes efficiently to minimize travel time between locations.
  2. Consider visiting multiple connected locations in a single trip to gather more information at once.
  3. Take advantage of shortcuts or alternative means of transportation mentioned in the casebook or newspaper articles.
Eliminate unnecessary visits
  1. Only visit locations likely to provide valuable clues.
  2. Eliminate dead-end leads early by carefully evaluating the relevance and potential of each location.
  3. Prioritize visits to crucial places that could provide breakthrough information.

By maximizing your efficiency throughout the investigation, you’ll save valuable time, make better progress, and ultimately enhance your chances of successfully solving the mysteries plaguing Victorian London. Ensure proper prioritization, efficient note-taking, strategic travel planning, and streamlined location visits to achieve optimal efficiency and claim victory in your quest for truth.

Interpreting Clues and Evidence

Mastering the art of interpreting clues and evidence is key to solving the intricate mysteries in Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases. Here are some strategies to help you effectively analyze and interpret the information you gather:

Connect the dots
  1. Look for connections and correlations among different pieces of evidence.
  2. Analyze how individual clues may intersect and provide a unified picture of the case.
  3. Consider the relationships between suspects, locations, and events to identify hidden motives and uncover the truth.
Consider context and subtext
  1. Pay attention to the context in which clues are revealed and analyze their significance based on the situation.
  2. Look beyond the literal meaning of statements or hints and consider possible hidden messages or subtext.
  3. Examine the nuances and subtleties in witness testimonies to identify potential discrepancies or hidden agendas.
Think critically
  1. Apply critical thinking to evaluate the veracity and reliability of the information you encounter.
  2. Question assumptions, challenge biases, and seek alternate interpretations of the evidence.
  3. Consider different angles and perspectives to gain a comprehensive understanding of the case.
Seek expert opinions
  1. Reach out to in-game experts or seek opinions from characters who possess specialized knowledge or insights.
  2. Consult external resources, such as historical references or other materials related to the game, to gain additional perspectives.
  3. Use expert advice as a valuable tool in guiding your interpretations and steering your investigation in the right direction.

By effectively interpreting clues and evidence, you’ll be equipped with the insights and knowledge needed to crack the complex cases in Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective. Train your mind to think critically, analyze context, connect the dots, and seek expert advice to unravel the mysteries and emerge triumphant in your investigative endeavors.

Managing Time

Time management is crucial in Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases, as you navigate the intricate mysteries within a limited timeframe. Here are some strategies to help you effectively manage your time and accomplish your investigation goals:

Set priorities
  1. Evaluate the importance and relevance of different leads and clues.
  2. Identify the most pressing tasks and allocate your time accordingly.
  3. Focus on high-priority leads that can contribute significantly to your investigation.
Plan your schedule
  1. Create a thorough timeline or schedule to keep track of your investigation progress.
  2. Account for travel time between locations and plan your visits strategically.
  3. Set specific time slots for important tasks, like interviewing suspects or gathering critical information.
Stay organized
  1. Maintain a well-organized casebook and note-taking system.
  2. Keep all your collected information, clues, and evidence in a structured manner.
  3. Ensure quick and easy access to relevant information when needed, saving precious time during the investigation.
Avoid unnecessary detours
  1. Eliminate leads that are unlikely to be productive or offer valuable insights.
  2. Avoid getting sidetracked by unrelated information or tangents.
  3. Resist the temptation to visit unnecessary locations that won’t aid your investigation significantly.

By effectively managing your time, setting priorities, planning your schedule, and staying organized, you’ll optimize your investigation process and increase your chances of success. Implement these strategies to navigate the intricate cases efficiently and emerge as a skilled detective with a reputation for solving even the most challenging mysteries.

Reviewing Official Solutions

Reviewing the official solutions provided in Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases can offer invaluable insights and improve your detective skills. Here are some strategies to effectively utilize the official solutions:

Compare and contrast
  1. Carefully analyze the official solutions in comparison to your own conclusions.
  2. Consider the differences in your deductions and identify areas to improve.
  3. Look for missed clues or overlooked evidence that influenced the outcome.
Analyze the thought process
  1. Examine the logical progression of the solutions and the reasoning behind them.
  2. Understand how the developers intended for the case to be solved.
  3. Note any key elements or patterns in the official solutions that you may have missed.
Learn from mistakes
  1. Take note of any incorrect or misleading assumptions made during your investigation.
  2. Identify areas where you failed to gather crucial information.
  3. Acknowledge mistakes as learning opportunities to refine your detective skills.
Implement new strategies
  1. Integrate new techniques and problem-solving approaches used in the official solutions into your own playstyle.
  2. Experiment with different deduction methodologies and logic pathways outlined in the solution.
  3. Apply your improved understanding to future cases and adapt your approach accordingly.

By reviewing the official solutions, you can gain valuable insights, identify areas for improvement, and refine your detective abilities. Analyze the thought process, learn from mistakes, and implement new strategies to enhance your problem-solving skills and increase your chances of unraveling the mysteries with precision.


Congratulations! You have now gained valuable insights from our strategy guide for Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases. Armed with knowledge of the game rules and top strategies, you are ready to embark on a thrilling journey through the dark streets of Victorian London as a master detective.

Remember to establish effective planning techniques, maximize efficiency in your investigations, interpret clues and evidence with precision, manage your time wisely, and analyze the official solutions for continuous improvement.

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective offers an immersive and challenging gaming experience that will put your deduction skills to the ultimate test. Dive deep into the mysteries that unfold before you, gather crucial information, and unravel the truth.

Prepare yourself for hours of suspense, intrigue, and mind-bending puzzles as you strive to solve each case with brilliance. May your deductive reasoning and keen observation pave the way to triumph! So, put on your detective hat and get ready to become the savior of Victorian London!

Want to know what we think of Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases? Read our detailed review of Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases here

Jamie in his proper element: With all of his board games
Jamie Hopkins

With years of dice-rolling, card-flipping, and strategic planning under my belt, I've transformed my passion into expertise. I thrive on dissecting the mechanics and social dynamics of board games, sharing insights from countless game nights with friends. I dive deep into gameplay mechanics, while emphasizing the social joys of gaming. While I appreciate themes and visuals, it's the strategy and camaraderie that truly capture my heart.