New Amsterdam: Box Cover Front
New Amsterdam - Last weekend I played my first game of Nieuw Amsterdam with my friends in Tokyo. - Credit: moonblogger
  1. New Amsterdam: Box Cover Front
  2. New Amsterdam - Last weekend I played my first game of Nieuw Amsterdam with my friends in Tokyo. - Credit: moonblogger

New Amsterdam Review

New Amsterdam impresses with its rich historical theme, strategic gameplay, and high-quality components. Though the card edges might wear over time, it's a minor issue in an otherwise stellar game. A must-try for strategy enthusiasts!
  • Theme and Setting
  • Gameplay and Strategy
  • Player Interaction
  • Component Quality
4.3/5Overall Score

Explore New Amsterdam's strategic gameplay, engaging historical theme, and high-quality components in this insightful and entertaining review!

Specs
  • Number of players: 2-5
  • Playing Time: 90-120 minutes
  • Recommended player age: 12+
  • Designer: Jeffrey D. Allers
  • Publisher: White Goblin Games
  • Theme: 1600s Dutch trading post, New Amsterdam
  • Mechanics: Bidding, Area Control, Set Collection
Pros
  • Immersive historical theme
  • Strategic gameplay
  • High-quality components
  • Engaging bidding mechanics
Cons
  • Card edges wear quickly
  • Complex for new players
  • Limited player interaction
Disclaimer: Clicking our links may result in us earning enough for a new pair of dice, but not enough to quit our day jobs as amateur board game hustlers.

Hey there, board game lovers! Gather ’round because today, I’m reviewing New Amsterdam. This game takes us back to the 1600s when Dutch traders were busy building a bustling trading post. From intense bidding wars to strategic land acquisitions, this game promises a blend of historical charm and gripping gameplay. But does it live up to the hype? Let’s find out!

How It Plays

Setting Up

First, set up the board. Each player gets a player board, land tiles, and six settlers. Place the land tiles in the land market and the action tiles in the action market. Determine the starting player and hand out initial resources: furs, coins, and a land claim per player.

Gameplay

Each round has three phases: Auction, Action, and Upkeep. During the Auction phase, players bid on action tiles with coins. The highest bidder chooses first, and so on. In the Action phase, players use action tiles to perform actions like trading furs, gaining resources, or expanding land. The Upkeep phase involves resetting for the next round, including moving settlers and preparing new action tiles.

Winning the Game

After a set number of rounds, tally points from land tiles, fur trading, and special deeds. The player with the most points wins. Victory comes from balancing resource management, strategic bidding, and land expansion.

Want to know more? Read our extensive strategy guide for New Amsterdam.

Delving into the Rich Historical Theme of New Amsterdam

If you’re a history buff, New Amsterdam will transport you back to the early 1600s. This game is set in the time when the Dutch West India Company was making its mark on the New World. The game’s theme revolves around the founding and development of New Amsterdam, which we now know as New York City. The developers have brilliantly captured the essence of the era. It’s like taking a time machine back to when beavers were far more valuable than bitcoins!

You get to immerse yourself in the vibrant atmosphere of the trading outposts, negotiate with Native Americans, and establish settlements. The artwork is impressive. It feels like each card could be a page ripped straight from a history book. The player boards, designed to resemble old-world maps, add that authentic touch.

One thing I appreciate about New Amsterdam is how it balances historical fidelity with gameplay. You don’t need to be a historian to enjoy it, but if you know your stuff, you’ll find plenty of easter eggs. From trading beaver pelts to navigating the political landscape of the Dutch colonies, everything feels interconnected. This game is not just about winning; it’s about experiencing and shaping a fascinating piece of history. Dare I say, it’s way more fun than a night with a history textbook!

I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention how the setting influences the game’s mechanics. And speaking of mechanics, stay tuned because you won’t want to miss the next section on Game mechanics and balance.

New Amsterdam - Last weekend I played my first game of Nieuw Amsterdam with my friends in Tokyo. - Credit: moonblogger

Array

Player Interaction and Strategy in New Amsterdam

When it comes to player interaction and strategy, New Amsterdam has more layers than an onion. I remember sitting around the table with my friends, and it felt like we were all scheming in a secret council meeting. The game’s clever mechanics force you to pay attention to what everyone else is doing, making each decision count.

In New Amsterdam, players take on the roles of influential merchants in the Dutch trading colony. Unlike some games where you can focus on your own board and ignore everyone else, this game makes you keep an eagle eye on your opponents. For example, bidding in the action phase is intense. There’s a delicate balance between going all out on an auction and keeping enough resources for later moves. I once got carried away and ended up unable to buy the land I wanted, much to the amusement of my friends.

One of the game’s standout features is the land acquisition. You can grab some prime real estate, but you better believe your friends will be eyeing that same spot. The player who manages to get territory without overly stretching their resources often comes out on top. It’s a bit like playing poker, where reading the room and knowing when to fold your cards makes all the difference.

Then there are the Native American alliances. Creating alliances can yield valuable furs and resources, but misstep, and you’ll leave the door open for your opponents to swoop in and snag those deals.

Next up, I’ll get into the components quality and artwork, because the pieces in this game are something to behold.

New Amsterdam: Components Quality and Artwork

Alright, folks, let’s talk about components quality and artwork in New Amsterdam. If you’re anything like me, you’ve got a soft spot for games that look good on the table. New Amsterdam does not disappoint in this department. From the moment you crack open the box, you can tell the makers poured a lot of love into this one.

First off, the board is a work of art itself. It’s got that vintage map feel, like something you’d find in an old sea captain’s chest. The details really pop, making you feel like you’ve been transported back to 17th-century Manhattan. The artist nailed it right on the head. You can almost hear the bustling port and feel the salty air.

The components—oh boy, let’s talk bits and pieces. The wooden meeples and tokens are sturdy and nice to handle. No flimsy cardboard chits here, my friends! The player boards are thick, and the cards have that satisfying shuffle feel. However, I did notice that after several games, the card edges started to show wear. Nothing a good card sleeve won’t fix, but something to keep in mind.

On the artwork front, the illustrations on the cards and player boards are top-notch. Each image adds to the overall atmosphere and brings the historical theme to life. The colors are rich and vibrant without being too gaudy. It’s like each illustration tells a little story, which adds depth to your gaming experience.

So, do I recommend New Amsterdam based on components and artwork alone? Absolutely! It’s a visual and tactile delight that will enhance any game night. Just remember to sleeve those cards if you’re as finicky about your game’s lifespan as I am.

Conclusion

New Amsterdam whisks you back to the 1600s, where every decision can set you up for triumph or doom. From intense bidding wars to strategic land grabs, this game offers a rich, immersive experience. The components and artwork are top-notch, though keep an eye on those card edges. While the historical theme is engaging and the gameplay intricate, a little luck here and there doesn’t hurt. If you enjoy strategy with a touch of history, New Amsterdam deserves a spot on your shelf. This concludes my review. Happy gaming!

4.3/5Overall Score
Jamie in his proper element: With all of his board games
Jamie Hopkins

With years of dice-rolling, card-flipping, and strategic planning under my belt, I've transformed my passion into expertise. I thrive on dissecting the mechanics and social dynamics of board games, sharing insights from countless game nights with friends. I dive deep into gameplay mechanics, while emphasizing the social joys of gaming. While I appreciate themes and visuals, it's the strategy and camaraderie that truly capture my heart.