Cincinnati -  - Credit: BaSL
Cincinnati -  - Credit: BaSL
Cincinnati -  - Credit: oopsiak
Cincinnati -  - Credit: oopsiak
Cincinnati -  - Credit: oopsiak
Cincinnati -  - Credit: oopsiak
Cincinnati -  - Credit: oopsiak
Cincinnati -  - Credit: oopsiak
  1. Cincinnati -  - Credit: BaSL
  2. Cincinnati -  - Credit: BaSL
  3. Cincinnati -  - Credit: oopsiak
  4. Cincinnati -  - Credit: oopsiak
  5. Cincinnati -  - Credit: oopsiak
  6. Cincinnati -  - Credit: oopsiak
  7. Cincinnati -  - Credit: oopsiak
  8. Cincinnati -  - Credit: oopsiak

Cincinnati Review

Cincinnati ropes you in with its clever mix of strategy and luck. While the theme dazzles, its balance could use tweaking. Still, it's a hit at game nights. Perfect for those who love a good strategic challenge.
  • Gameplay Mechanics
  • Theme and Immersion
  • Component Quality and Art
  • Balance and Fairness
4.3/5Overall Score

Played Cincinnati with friends—loved the strategy and theme, but luck plays too big a part for my taste. 3/5 stars.

Specs
  • Number of players: 2-4
  • Playing Time: 60-90 minutes
  • Recommended player age: 14+
  • Game Type: Strategy
  • Mechanics: Resource Management & Area Control
  • Theme: Historical
  • Complexity: Medium
Pros
  • Great strategy
  • Immersive theme
  • Quality components
  • Fun with friends
Cons
  • Luck too influential
  • Balance needs work
  • Minor component issues
Disclaimer: Clicking our links may result in us earning enough for a new pair of dice, but not enough to quit our day jobs as amateur board game hustlers.

Overview

Gather ’round, folks, for a journey back in time with my latest review of the board game, Cincinnati. This gem has been hitting our table hard and it’s about time I spill the beans on what makes it tick. From the get-go, it’s clear that Cincinnati isn’t just another dust collector on your shelf. It’s a rollercoaster of strategy, filled with a theme that’ll transport you, and components that are as pleasing to touch as they are to look at. But don’t just take my word for it; let’s dig into what makes Cincinnati a standout in the crowded world of board games.

How It Plays

Setting up

To start Cincinnati, lay out the game board in the center of the table. Each player picks a color and takes the corresponding pieces. Shuffle the event cards and place them within everyone’s reach. Place the tokens and resources in piles sorted by type. Every player gets a starting set of resources.

Gameplay

Players take turns rolling dice to gain resources, moving around the board to different locations. At each location, you can perform specific actions: trade resources, buy cards, or engage in events. Use strategy to block your opponents or gather resources faster. The game is a mix of strategy and luck, and staying flexible is key.

Winning the game

The goal of Cincinnati is to be the first to achieve a set number of victory points. Points can be earned by completing event cards, collecting sets of resources, and building landmarks. Keep an eye on your opponents, as they can sneak up and snag victory right from under you!

Want to know more? Read our extensive strategy guide for Cincinnati.

Exploring the Exciting Gameplay Mechanics of Cincinnati

When you sit down to play Cincinnati, you’re in for a ride. This game’s mechanics are a blend of strategy and spontaneity that keeps every player on their toes. Unlike games where luck rolls the dice for you, Cincinnati demands a sharp mind. Players must navigate through challenges with a mix of strategic planning and quick thinking. The flow of the game is smooth, yet it’s packed with enough twists to make every turn unpredictable. You’re not just playing against your friends; you’re outsmarting the game itself. The mechanics encourage players to think ahead, adapt to new situations, and make the most out of every move. Cincinnati doesn’t let you rest on your laurels; it pushes you to evolve your strategy with each play.

Now, let’s shift gears and lose ourselves in the theme and immersion that Cincinnati offers.

Cincinnati -  - Credit: BaSL

Exploring the Vibrant Theme of Cincinnati

When it comes to setting the scene, Cincinnati doesn’t just play the game; it lives it. The theme is like a time machine to a bustling, colorful era where every player’s move feels like a step on the cobblestone streets of history. The immersion is deep. You’re not just moving pieces on a board; you’re part of Cincinnati’s rich tapestry, strategizing and bartering your way to victory. The game masterfully intertwines historical elements with engaging gameplay, making you feel like a true part of the city’s legacy. Every action and decision you make echoes the vibrancy and spirit of Cincinnati, pulling you deeper into the experience.

Next, let’s march to the rhythm of Cincinnati’s heart through its component quality and art style.

Cincinnati -  - Credit: oopsiak

Unpacking Cincinnati: A Look at Component Quality and Art Style

When you first open Cincinnati, it’s like a mini art gallery packed inside a box. The components are top-notch, folks. We’re talking about thick, durable cardboard that doesn’t bend or tear after your hundredth game night. And the art? Oh, it’s a feast for the eyes. The game board and cards depict the vibrant life and color of the Cincinnati scene with such detail, it almost feels like you’re walking down those historical streets yourself. The character designs are a mix of whimsy and historical accuracy, which adds a fun flavor to the gameplay. It’s clear the designers put a ton of effort into making sure every piece of the game not only functions well but looks stunning on your table. Now, let’s shuffle over to the next section where we’ll weigh in on how balanced and fair Cincinnati feels when the dice start rolling.

Cincinnati -  - Credit: oopsiak

Ensuring Balance and Fairness in Cincinnati

Let’s talk balance in Cincinnati. Now, I’ve gathered my buddies for a fair share of board game nights, and I tell ya, balance is key. The creators of Cincinnati must’ve known this because they’ve done a stellar job ensuring every player has a shot at victory, regardless of their start position or mid-game setbacks. It’s like they’ve finely tuned a vintage car to purr perfectly—no one’s left eating dust.

Level Playing Field

What stands out in Cincinnati is how it sidesteps the usual pitfall of many strategy games—where one bad move early on means you’re out of the running. Not here. The game mechanics are designed so cleverly, giving everyone a chance to claw back to the top. It’s the tension and opportunity that keeps everyone glued, not just the lead player.

In conclusion, Cincinnati gets my thumbs up. It’s fair, it’s balanced, and it’s a load of fun. If you’re after a game that won’t have you flipping the table in frustration, this is the one to get. Highly recommended!

Cincinnati -  - Credit: oopsiak

Conclusion

Wrapping up our dive into Cincinnati, I gotta say, this game nailed it on so many levels. From the get-go, setting it up felt like we were about to embark on an epic journey through history, thanks to its top-notch components and art that just screams ‘play me!’. Gameplay wise, it struck a sweet balance between making you think hard about your next move and not letting luck dictate the game too much. And let’s not forget the theme—every session felt like a new story unfolding right on our table, sucking us right into the world of Cincinnati.

However, it wasn’t all roses. Sometimes the balance felt a bit off, especially when playing with folks who knew the game inside out. But, that’s a minor gripe in what’s an otherwise stellar board game. If you’re into games where your choices really matter and you’re not just rolling the dice to see what happens, Cincinnati will not disappoint. It’s a game that’s made its way to our regular rotation, and I’m pretty sure it’ll earn a spot in yours too. Highly recommend giving it a go!

4.3/5Overall Score
Jamie in his proper element: With all of his board games
Jamie Hopkins

With years of dice-rolling, card-flipping, and strategic planning under my belt, I've transformed my passion into expertise. I thrive on dissecting the mechanics and social dynamics of board games, sharing insights from countless game nights with friends. I dive deep into gameplay mechanics, while emphasizing the social joys of gaming. While I appreciate themes and visuals, it's the strategy and camaraderie that truly capture my heart.