Best 5 Supernatural Investigations Board Games of 2024 Reviewed

Explore the best supernatural investigations board games. From Mysterium to Mansions of Madness, these games promise thrilling, spooky detective adventures.
Disclaimer: Clicking our links may result in us earning enough for a new pair of dice, but not enough to quit our day jobs as amateur board game hustlers.
Mysterium coverArkham Horror: The Card Game coverBetrayal at House on the Hill cover

Hey there, fellow board game enthusiasts! If you’re like us, anything that involves supernatural investigations gets your heart racing and your dice ready. We’ve scoured the spooky corners of the board game world to bring you our top 5 picks that will have you solving mysteries, facing off against eerie creatures, and maybe even betraying your friends. When choosing our favorites, we focused on the theme, gameplay variety, and, of course, the ability to bring us to the edge of our seats with suspense. So grab your flashlight and detective hat; we’re about to embark on an adventure through haunted mansions, cursed towns, and timelines filled with terror!

On this list:

5 Mysterium

Mysterium cover

  • Age Range: 10+
  • Players: 2-7
  • Play Time: 42 min

Get your copy on Amazon ↗

Kicking off our list, Mysterium sets players up for a ghostly good time. We’ve all huddled around this board, trying to suss out the whispers from the afterlife. A cooperative affair, it’s like Clue met a séance. One player is the ghost, dropping cryptic clues to help the others solve a murder. What’s not to love? It’s part guessing game, part deduction, and all fun. Plus, the artwork? Gorgeous.

4 Arkham Horror: The Card Game

Arkham Horror: The Card Game cover

  • Age Range: 14+
  • Players: 1-2
  • Play Time: 60-120 min

Get your copy on Amazon ↗

This one draws you into the creepy, crawly world of H.P. Lovecraft. It’s not just a game; it’s an experience. You’re not playing; you’re investigating. Every choice feels heavy, like it might just tip the scales between sanity and madness. We’ve lost more nights to this game than we care to admit, delving into dark mysteries and supernatural investigations that always leave us wanting more. The narrative depth here is unmatched.

3 Betrayal at House on the Hill

Betrayal at House on the Hill cover

  • Age Range: 12+
  • Players: 3-6
  • Play Time: 60 min

Get your copy on Amazon ↗

Now, here’s a twisty turner for you. It starts as a team game. We’re all friends exploring a spooky house. But then, bam! Midway, one of us becomes the traitor. The game shifts. It becomes a race against time and each other. The supernatural investigations turn inward, as we figure out who’s plotting our doom. It’s a rollercoaster of emotions and hilarity, with a dash of betrayal. Never gets old.

2 Eldritch Horror

Eldritch Horror cover

  • Age Range: 14+
  • Players: 1-8
  • Play Time: 120-240 min

Get your copy on Amazon ↗

This game is a globetrotting adventure, filled with ancient gods and bizarre happenings. Think of it as Arkham Horror’s big brother. You’re part of a team of investigators, traveling the world, sealing portals and stopping unspeakable horrors. The scope is epic, and so are the game nights. We’ve sat breathless, dice in hand, hoping to stave off the apocalypse one more time. Every playthrough is a saga.

1 Mansions of Madness: Second Edition

Mansions of Madness: Second Edition cover

  • Age Range: 14+
  • Players: 1-5
  • Play Time: 120-180 min

Get your copy on Amazon ↗

Now, if we had to crown a king of supernatural investigations, it’s Mansions of Madness: Second Edition, hands down. This is not just a game; it’s an event. Why is it the best? Because it combines everything we love: a gripping story, immersive gameplay, and an app that takes it to the next level. Every session is unique with the app guiding the horror. We’ve screamed, laughed, and maybe cried a bit, but always ended the night eager for the next mystery. It’s the perfect blend of technology and tradition.

Jamie in his proper element: With all of his board games
Jamie Hopkins

With years of dice-rolling, card-flipping, and strategic planning under my belt, I've transformed my passion into expertise. I thrive on dissecting the mechanics and social dynamics of board games, sharing insights from countless game nights with friends. I dive deep into gameplay mechanics, while emphasizing the social joys of gaming. While I appreciate themes and visuals, it's the strategy and camaraderie that truly capture my heart.